Kurt A. Sanftleben, LLC

Scott was the most important officer ever to serve in the U.S. Army and served from 1808 until 1861. Astonishingly, he was a general officer for 47 of those 53 years and during that time was principally responsible for American success in the War of 1812 and the Mexican-American War. He was diplomatically astute and played a key role in diffusing the Patriot War, the Nullification Crisis, and implementing the Indian Removal as humanely as possible. As well, although Scott did not command forces during the Civil War, it was his Anaconda Plan the split the Confederacy in two and ultimately strangled the eastern half by capturing the Mississippi River and, somewhat less effectively blockading Southern ports.

I have been unable to determine if Ingersoll’s request was granted by John C. Spencer. However, as an interesting aside. Spencer’s son, Philip, is more famous (well, actually notorious) than his father. Philip was an incorrigible, wild, and uncontrollable young man who as a boy was fascinated by pirates. After expulsions from Geneva (now Hobart) and Union Colleges (where he founded Chi Psi ( ) fraternity, his father, by then the War Secretary, easily purchased a midshipman’s commission for Philip in the U.S. Navy. Continuing his horrendous behavior, Philip was removed from two vessels, the USS North Carolina and the USS John Adams for drunkenness, insubordination, and brawling. However, he was not cashiered because of his father’s position. He ended up aboard the USS Somers where he rapidly alienated the captain and other officers and became drinking and smoking buddies with the crew, especially two sailor swhom it was rumored had previously served on slavers and with pirates. After the men’s behavior suggested they were plotting to mutiny, seize the Somers to use as a pirate ship, their belongs were searched. Unfortunately for them, the search turned up an incriminating slip of paper in Philip’s shaving kit that was written in Greek, and all were shackled to the foredeck. The next morning, after a deliberation between the captain and his other officers, they were hanged from the yardarm without court-martial. Their hanging was well-published throughout the country, and although public opinion was split, the captain and officers were exonerated by a court of inquiry. Philip’s execution was the driving force that stopped the navy’s on-board sea training of boys and young men to become officers and led to the establishment of the U. S. Naval Academy at Annapolis. Herman Mehlville, whose cousin was an officer aboard the USS Somers and a first -hand witness of Philip’s hanging, based Billy Budd upon the incident.

(For more information see, Graves’s The Battle of Lundy's Lane, On the Niagara in 1814, McPherson’s Battle Cry of Freedom, “Scott, Winfield” in the 11th edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica, and Melton’s A Hanging Offense: The Strange Affair of the Warship Somers.)

Documents and letters signed by Scott are scarce. At the time of listing, there are three signed letters for sale in the trade, and the Rare Book Hub shows that four have been sold at auction since 2000. OCLC reports Scott letters are held at only four institutions.